News

NewsSuffer through the cold and heat no more: FiftyUp Club take members views to court
Suffer through the cold and heat no more: FiftyUp Club take members views to court

Suffer through the cold and heat no more: FiftyUp Club take members views to court

The stakes in this court battle could hardly be higher.

A tribunal is deciding if your power bills will actually go down or unbelievably climb by almost $6 billion over the next four years.

But given the public anger about bills, which have already doubled in the past five years, it’s all very polite. At the tribunal a smiling informal judge greet us and there’s home-made scones for morning tea.

We’re readying our papers at the Australian Competition Tribunal sitting to in Sydney ready to bring your voice to the three men who face a mighty decision.

Should the Australian Energy Regulator’s (AER) price determination meaning power price cuts from $106-313 a year for average households stand?

Or do the energy networks, which distribute electricity through poles and wires, deserve a break so they can ensure a bush-fire safe and reliable supply?

It matters to you which is why the FiftyUp Club has a platform for 15 minutes to convey the opinions of 5,000 who responded and shared 800 comments from the two surveys we’ve conducted on this issue.

There are packs of lawyers, the media and interested parties from around the state and beyond seated on the opulent 20th floor of the Federal Court.

It’s not everyday consumers are given a box-seat near to the seat of power to get their interests ventilated and if this had happened five years ago one wonders if power prices would have spiked so high.

We are among the first off with the key message that affordability is by far the single most important priority for you when it comes to interests.

The tribunal has to weigh up the long-term interests of consumers, which includes you as well as everyone from farmers to industry, with respect to price, quality, safety, reliability and security.

You were clear what you wanted.

The survey shows overwhelming support for the AER’s decision with 74% agreeing with the statement “We've been paying too much for too long.”

An overwhelming 96% considered such interests had not been adequately considered in the past. You clearly rated issues such as affordability (77%) ahead of reliability (9%), safety (9%) and quality (4%).

And 85% believed the regulators such as the AER had not got the balance right between these competing aims. Only 3% thought they had.

Over-50's such as Charles Falzon from Western Sydney shared his opinion in the submission.

Click Here to read the FiftyUp Club submission

Click Here to read the May survey

Click Here to read the June survey

The comments we did read out included:

"Go to Bed at 7pm-8am then go and sit in shopping Centre if too cold."

"Drop to a much lower standard of living.eg  no heaters or fans . Suffer through heat and cold. less showers etc."

"Use the A/C sparingly, less baked Dinners."

Time flew by quickly and there was just time to make an often overlooked point. We are all in debt to the networks’ ability to bring the wonders of electricity to us day-in and day-out is usually taken for granted.

That being said it was your view that we shouldn’t be in debt to pay the bills and it was time for the networks to tighten their belts as we deserve relief not added costs.

The Tribunal members asked some piercing questions showing they had listened carefully and thoroughly to us, thanked you, for your input.

It’s not over and with so much money at stake you won’t have heard the last of this process but for Day One the FiftyUp Club had a pretty good showing.

 

Originally posted on .

Join the conversation

FiftyUp Club
FiftyUp Club members views are shared with the court over electricity prices

Share your views with other members. 

Want to leave a comment? or .
Read our moderation policy here.
Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

'This nonsense had better not be because of the sale of the poles and wires,something we were assured would not happen. 

Claudia
Claudia from VIC commented:

Yes well what happened to the SEC.We continue to allow governments to sell us out to foreign ownership. So we must pay the price.Do you really think that we can access cheaper utilities.The gate is open the horse has bolted. 

karen
karen from NSW commented:

I work in the retail industry and have lost count of the number of elderly pensioners who say that they turn their power off a couple of days a week to afford bills. They sit by the light of candles, eat sandwiches for dinner, shiver when it's cold and don't use their fans or a/c's. It's probably safe to presume that the number of elderly people being admitted to hospital or dying will increase if there is no relief from ever climbing power bills - electricity AND gas 

Someone
Someone from NSW replied to karen:

its a disgrace china gets our coal for cheap electricity, i freeze or have no cooling system, why are we being punished? 

Janelle
Janelle from NSW commented:

Thankyou everybody for fighting for the people who can least afford these very high electricity prices. 

Warren
Warren from NSW commented:

Most people have no idea (clueless) of the intricate issues regarding energy prices. ‘Emotion’ always plays the trump card and sucks them in. There goes another ‘bang’. Bill Shorten announced a reboot of C02 tax without any modelling on energy costs and the lefties want a target for 50% derived from renewable sources by 2030 – another $80 Billion thought bubble from Labor/Greens. Who is paying for this? We know that reliable Coal has a cost factor of $36 megawatts/hour. Unreliable Solar is 5.3 times this cost followed by Hydro 4.2, Wind 3.4, and Gas 2.6 times that of Coal energy generation. We’ve all been sold a pup on energy prices. Go back to coal I say. Cheap, more efficient and the C02 emissions allow plants/trees grow faster. 

Brian
Brian from NSW commented:

Maybe the technology used for the survey worked against us, remember we are all over fifty and computers may not be the method of choice for the majority of our members. It may require a phone survey after the initial electronic survey has run its course. A pleasant person on the phone would be less daunting to some. 

ian
ian from NSW commented:

yeah Robert , pretty poor effort. p.s. I think my math's need improving ,it was 116,000 . Ian nsw 

ian
ian from NSW commented:

I cant believe that only 9,000 members out of 125,000 signed up to protest on electricity pricing. Are you all rich or just cant be bothered ? Poor mr zinn is out there fighting for us for a fair go, and I think 114,000 members let him down badly. Ian nsw. 

robert
robert from NSW replied to ian:

I couldn't agree more with you Ian,my only defence for most of them would have to be that they are no longer turning on their computers except to pay bills online. 

margaret
margaret from NSW replied to ian:

Frankly I can believe this. The once vibrant 'Club' may have many members however the numbers relate to those who signed up not those who are now actively involved at this point. What was once an and open interesting discussion group has now been redirected to topics of INTEREST???? to those running the club and was then taken over by a few bored and discontented humans who did not seem to have much to do with their time other to sit at their computers and share their unhappiness with the world. Also we should understand that even if the club had more interest points some people will sign up for anything free, especially if it gives them a chance to whinge along with the vague belief that someone will then drop manna upon them thus solving their perceived problems. They soon become disillusioned and whilst their name is 'still on the roll' and inflates membership numbers, they really are not active members. 

ian
ian from NSW replied to margaret:

not sure if you agree or disagree with my comment, but either way you sure have a way with words Margaret.....Ian nsw. 

Comment Guidelines