News

NewsHow Australian is 'Australian Made'?
How Australian is 'Australian Made'?

How Australian is 'Australian Made'?

It was clearly labelled “ Aussie Beer” complete with a map of Australia and green and gold colours… yet it was brewed in China.

Or the ‘just caught prawn meat’, again with an Aussie map and flag, which while caught locally was actually processed and packaged in Thailand.

Such are the half-truths, and sometimes outright deceptions, which have copped fines recently from the genuinely true blue Australia Competition and Consumer Commission.

So while memories of our national day are still warm here’s a quick guide of how to decipher some of the porkies and small print around sneaky country of origin labels for food and drink.

And the good news is that soon they’ll be much better labels with more graphic information and reliable logos, complete with a kangaroo, to help you decide.

The problem in part has arisen as globalisation has given us access to once exotic foodstuffs from all over the world. Generally this is good and last week I even found frozen avocado from Peru in the supermarket.

But it can leave a sour taste in our mouths when merchants seek to exploit our desire to buy local with confusing descriptions.

Claims such as made in, grown in or product of Australia might imply the obvious to most of us but they have specific and differing definitions.

For example ‘Product of’, which usually applies to processed foods, if attached to something like smoked salmon means the fish was both caught and smoked in Australia.

If ‘Grown in Australia’ is attached to a piece of fruit it means just that in Oz not anywhere else.  These two descriptions are for now the simplest way to buy Australian.

With the term ‘Made in’, things get a bit more complex.   The ACCC says it means the food must have been manufactured, and not just packed in Australia, and at least 50% of the costs of processing must have been incurred in this country.

The ingredients might not even have come from Australia. The ACCC gives the example of jam. More than half the cost of making it might have been paid here but the fruit and/or sugar could have come from elsewhere.

The label which drives many consumers batty is ‘Made in Australia from local and imported ingredients’ which can mean anything and reveal nothing.

In part things are going to get better. Last July the federal government released the designs for new country-of-origin labels, which will specify the percentage of Australian produce in any foodstuff.

But there’s still no requirement to spell out where all of the key ingredients might be sourced from if they are not from Australia. CHOICE gives the example of ice cream. The dairy products might be proudly Australian and the consumer is left in the dark as to where the berries within might come from

Check out the new look labels and see if they will make your shopping any easier. People chose to buy Australian, which can sometimes but not always cost a bit more, for many reasons such as taste, purity even loyalty.

Whatever the reason the consumer has to have confidence in the product and that it comes from where they have good reason to believe it comes from. Aussie Beer, flags, maps all indicate a provenance of Australia. You shouldn’t have the read the fine print at the back of the pack to be sure.

PS

Some foods and other products claim to be ‘proudly Australian owned’ or ‘100% Aussie owned’. It might tell you about who the brand belongs to but doesn’t mean a thing as to where the product was made or where it’s ingredients/components came from.

Originally posted on .

Join the conversation

FiftyUp Club
How Australian is 'Australian Made'?

Share your views with other members. 

Want to leave a comment? or .
Read our moderation policy here.
Max
Max from NSW commented:

Labelling of products should be strictly controlled. If a product is grown or sourced in Australia it should say where it was from and whether it has been sent overseas for some type of processing. Where a product contains items from overseas it should not be allowed to say made in Australia. It could perhaps say"assembled in Australia" or partially Australian. Perhaps Mr Hawke was correct when he said that by 2012 Australia would no longer be a manufacturing country but instead would be an importing country! 

Ken
Ken from SA commented:

I am totally amazed that our Federal Government allows these half truths and deception to continue. My wife and I have to check out every can, every packet, every, everything to ensure we are purchasing genuine Australian food and product where necessary for our own peace of mind. Looking for best quality, fruit and vegetable and on and on it goes. Fed up with it. So much for the green triangle Logo, worthless. 

Klaus
Klaus from VIC commented:

Any infringement on labeling " AUSSIE MADE " to not 100% locally produced GOODS should be SEVERELY fined. A special Authority must be set up to deal with these cases, so the courts don't get clogged up. Imported goods are fine, as long as they are not labeled deceptively. 

Howard
Howard from NSW commented:

I did not get enough space in my last comment to vent my anger over this matter. Again, our governments (of all persuasions) are completely pathetic in allowing our farms to be sold off to foreigners, obviously for their own interests. Under existing circumstances, it won't be long before we are importing ALL of our produce, some perhaps grown here, but processed (and most probably with no thought to health and quality factors) in China or elsewhere in Asia. Our governments appear to be willfully destroying our culture and access to the healthiest and purest farm produce in the world. I am too old now to worry too much for myself, but I fear for the future of our children and grandchildren, and future Australian generations. 

Karen
Karen from NSW replied to Howard:

Come now Howard. You know we mustn't upset the neighbours! Look what is happening with Australian baby formula. Individual people exporting huge quantities to China (and I don't mean the manufacturers) leaving local families with nothing on the shelves. This should be stopped too but wait! We can't upset the neighbours. Whilst those same 'neighbours' dump their second rate, potentially dangerous goods on Australia. What's worse, Australians are buying it. I am pretty sure it would stop if it remained on the shelf. Unfortunately, people want their out of season fruit and veg. 

Howard
Howard from NSW replied to Karen:

Yes Karen, I agree with you. I am past worrying about baby formular but I sympathize with those in our country who do have a problem obtaining what they need. No, we mustn't upset our neighbours. Stuff the neighbours. I believe that charity begins at home. If your house is on fire and the neighbours' house is on fire, you do what you can to protect YOUR house before you rush in to protect the neighbours' house.. The same applies to immigration. We can't support our own homeless, and afford our welfare and medical systems. How can we support an influx of so called refugees, reputedly some 67% of whom are 'economic refugees', looking for a handout and freebies in the 'land of honey' . Our country is in a major financial crisis and we have to put the brakes on before we go completely bust. We had a great country up until some years ago when government actions, or inactions, destroyed our manufacturing industries. Just about everything we are now forced to buy comes from China, even our flags and other 'Aussie' stuff. Shopping now is a tedious affair, trying to sort through the labeling. I call on more Australians to be more discerning about what they buy. 

Valerie
Valerie from QLD commented:

My bugbear is the fact that apparently we can no longer manufacture toiletries in Australia. 95% or more of soap or body wash is made in Asia. The same goes for toothpaste, although some is manufactured in South Africa or Germany. 

Nonnie
Nonnie from NSW replied to Valerie:

I buy Cedel toothpaste - made in Australia and an Australian Company to boot. 

Howard
Howard from NSW commented:

This monkey business has been going on for far too long. We are being royally deceived and cheated because our governments are too damned apathetic to nail the problem and, most of all, DO something positive and constructive about rectifying the situation. I went to buy some "New Zealand" whiting fillets recently, and found a label "packed in China". My God, don't Aust. and NZ have any packing plants. It's downright disgusting AND criminal. The consumer is left totally bamboozled by it all. We only buy FRESH when we can and, hopefully, it is LOCAL product, and absolutely NOTHING from China, if we can help it. One really wouldn't know though, would they??? hp2454 

Norm
Norm from VIC replied to Howard:

Howard, the fish is probably caught in New Zealand waters by a Chinese fishing vessel, before processing there and returning to us. The big retailers rely on the fact that shoppers are generally time poor, especially young mothers. I see what they buy at the checkout and am amazed at the amount of worthless junk food they pay top dollar for. Most of this is imported, but not all of it. However, Australia is currently beholden to several foreign governments for our continued existence, so we must not upset their exporters who can have their government lobby ours strongly on their behalf. 

Janelle
Janelle from NSW commented:

Shopping takes forever now because I read each and every label. I am now buying a lot of fresh produce from the hobby farmers, which I drive up to 1.5 - 2 hours to get to and I make my own jams, tomato sauces, pasta etc. Grocery shopping is at a minimum and at least not only am I supporting local farmers but I know what I am buying. Good fresh Australian produce. I just wish it was a lot simpler to buy Australian in the shops :( 

Debbie
Debbie from VIC commented:

Not very much the produce sits on the shelf shouting look at me l'm austalian l'm an ozzie but don't be fooled on very close inspection only using a magnifier sometimes 75 % of it is made of imported stuff 

Marianne
Marianne from NSW commented:

I always check country of origin on packaging, if it says imported, I don't buy, imported and local content, I don't buy. I only buy when it says local content only. Not hard to do, but getting harder as the writing gets smaller and hidden further. Fresh if it doesn't say product of Australia I just don't buy it, have gone without onions for 8 months as Coles was selling only USA onions. To buy goods manufactured here in Australia is getting even tougher as we no longer have footwear, fibre and many other manufacturers here. Be careful when buying store brands, most are imported from 3rd world countries. Just like those really cheap school clothes that have been advertised, the stores do not care about the conditions and wages of the people who make these clothes. I no longer buy anything from Country Road or Rivers, the goods are churned out in China, why pay a high price for that. 

Sandra
Sandra from QLD commented:

It has to be made simple for everyone. The Australian flag should only be on the packet/bag or what ever if it 100% Australian made/grown/ manufactured here in Australia. That is the truest Australian recognition. Manufactures/growers want the best of both sides of the coin so what about those who keep it in Australia 100% they truly deserve the flag 100%. 

Comment Guidelines