News

NewsHow Australian is 'Australian Made'?
How Australian is 'Australian Made'?

How Australian is 'Australian Made'?

It was clearly labelled “ Aussie Beer” complete with a map of Australia and green and gold colours… yet it was brewed in China.

Or the ‘just caught prawn meat’, again with an Aussie map and flag, which while caught locally was actually processed and packaged in Thailand.

Such are the half-truths, and sometimes outright deceptions, which have copped fines recently from the genuinely true blue Australia Competition and Consumer Commission.

So while memories of our national day are still warm here’s a quick guide of how to decipher some of the porkies and small print around sneaky country of origin labels for food and drink.

And the good news is that soon they’ll be much better labels with more graphic information and reliable logos, complete with a kangaroo, to help you decide.

The problem in part has arisen as globalisation has given us access to once exotic foodstuffs from all over the world. Generally this is good and last week I even found frozen avocado from Peru in the supermarket.

But it can leave a sour taste in our mouths when merchants seek to exploit our desire to buy local with confusing descriptions.

Claims such as made in, grown in or product of Australia might imply the obvious to most of us but they have specific and differing definitions.

For example ‘Product of’, which usually applies to processed foods, if attached to something like smoked salmon means the fish was both caught and smoked in Australia.

If ‘Grown in Australia’ is attached to a piece of fruit it means just that in Oz not anywhere else.  These two descriptions are for now the simplest way to buy Australian.

With the term ‘Made in’, things get a bit more complex.   The ACCC says it means the food must have been manufactured, and not just packed in Australia, and at least 50% of the costs of processing must have been incurred in this country.

The ingredients might not even have come from Australia. The ACCC gives the example of jam. More than half the cost of making it might have been paid here but the fruit and/or sugar could have come from elsewhere.

The label which drives many consumers batty is ‘Made in Australia from local and imported ingredients’ which can mean anything and reveal nothing.

In part things are going to get better. Last July the federal government released the designs for new country-of-origin labels, which will specify the percentage of Australian produce in any foodstuff.

But there’s still no requirement to spell out where all of the key ingredients might be sourced from if they are not from Australia. CHOICE gives the example of ice cream. The dairy products might be proudly Australian and the consumer is left in the dark as to where the berries within might come from

Check out the new look labels and see if they will make your shopping any easier. People chose to buy Australian, which can sometimes but not always cost a bit more, for many reasons such as taste, purity even loyalty.

Whatever the reason the consumer has to have confidence in the product and that it comes from where they have good reason to believe it comes from. Aussie Beer, flags, maps all indicate a provenance of Australia. You shouldn’t have the read the fine print at the back of the pack to be sure.

PS

Some foods and other products claim to be ‘proudly Australian owned’ or ‘100% Aussie owned’. It might tell you about who the brand belongs to but doesn’t mean a thing as to where the product was made or where it’s ingredients/components came from.

Originally posted on .

Join the conversation

FiftyUp Club
How Australian is 'Australian Made'?

Share your views with other members. 

Want to leave a comment? or .
Read our moderation policy here.
Clive
Clive from NSW commented:

Most labels are not honest in their descriptions 

Maria
Maria from QLD commented:

Maria I'm sorry as I don't how my comment became associated with you. I am Pete from NSW 

Maria
Maria from QLD commented:

Isles by country of origin would be a great move as suggested by Marilyn and Russ. Just imagine walking into the Supermarket and finding all your needs in one or two isles. I sometimes stop by the deli at my supermarkets to check out the seafood. When asked if I need assistance I politely tell them no as I am just checking out the League of Nations. I have never bought a Heinz product since I saw frozen veggies from china. If Heinz provides Chinese veggies to adults what the hell is in their baby food?? 

Maria
Maria from QLD commented:

Its about time someone did something about the labels and misperceptions. I never used to read any label but now I find myself reading just about every item. Some of that frozen fish, which as much as I try to avoid, I do find quite handy after a big day out with the kids is so deceiving. Last lot I had at home was that Sealord which stated on the front of the box that it was "caught in New Zealand waters". However when I had a look at the back of the box it stated "made from local and imported products". I have no idea where the fish is from now and will not buy again. I suspect the fish may have been caught in NZ as stated and perhaps then sent to some Asian country for crumbing. But that's just a wild guess. Its no wonder so many get sick after eating these days. The front of the packaging tells you one thing yet the back tells you something else. This needs to be fixed once and for all so we all know exactly where our foods are coming from. 

Marilyn
Marilyn from NSW commented:

If our government is so intent on importing food product from other country's to feed Australians.....than I would like to see the ACCC place quality control on any foods imported to Australia, so that we don't have the same problem of the frozen berry incident....let's make all the isles in the supermarket in the name of the country where the food is made and processed....China, Japan, Thieland and so on and so on....that way we have a choice as to which isle we wish to purchase our food. 

Theo
Theo from NSW replied to Marilyn:

Quality is controlled at the source and manufacture. After is packed can not be controlled. What can be done though is put in effect minimum standards and guidelines and enforce them, which is not done at the moment. 

Russ
Russ from VIC commented:

I sincerely wish that one of the supermarkets (even only a smaller player) would have the sense to put in a fully Australian aisle or section so it would not be necessary to waste time trying to read product labeling to buy Australian. They have no problem having sections dedicated to Asian, Mexican or other specialty foods so why not a fully Australian aisle or section, whether major branded or generic. I for one and i'm sure many others would make this a first stop always 

LEONIE
LEONIE from NSW commented:

Back in the sixties & seventies we had the capacity to manufacture, process & assembled most products & produce we use & consume each day. With the greed for the mighty dollar both from the floor thru to the executive offices wanting higher share returns, we have forced ourselves out of the market being susceptible to takeovers being unable to compete on the open market. On top of that our government reduced tariffs opening the door for overseas invasions of all products and even raw materials. What hope have we got, will only get worse, as we neglect all producers in lieu of the mighty dollar. The future for our grand kids is now only set up for the explosion of computers & cyber space invasion leaving the basic tasks out of the reach of our children, unable to do the necessary fundamentals required. 

Peter
Peter from QLD commented:

Why are our lily-livered, limp wristed politicians so petrified of enforcing accurate labelling, informing us of what is most important to us - where the product originates? If the Chinese, for example, were forced to correctly label their products, before entry into Australia, they might be forced to improve their hygiene standards etc. in order to sell them. As for halal certification - what a scandalous rort - once again a lack of intestinal fortitude on our part. 

Theo
Theo from NSW replied to Peter:

All products going out of China should and do carry "Made in China" or Made in PRC' its their law. 

Theo
Theo from NSW commented:

Hello All, in the beginning when the scanning codes were introduced codes were numbered according to country of origin. Australia has the codes starting with 93..... . This was controlled fairly well for some years but in the recent 10-15 years we see Australian codes on products that fit the category of "Australian Owned" but originated wholly abroad. Saying all that, the issue is clearly with the governors to draw and implement laws that such thinks are fraudulent and criminal. What a citizen can do is not "vote them out next time" but complain to their local representative and demand action. Also as individual complain to ACCA, irrespective of whether the product that offends them is in large supermarket shelf or small private shop. This will get the retailers to think twice before stocking those lines again. And last but not least, remember that merchants are there to make profit, their mantra is "buy cheap sell cheap" (to compete), or "buy cheap in abandance sell dear in demand" (to maximize profit). But they also want the trade. Groups and Clubs such as this can in a way represent the views of many, so would it be nice to have survey that addresses these issues and present the findings to the big companies and the governors? 

Robert
Robert from ACT commented:

Its a minefield. We also need to loom at ingredients - in particular sugar content ... many processed foods have high (around 10%) sugar. 

Comment Guidelines