News

NewsThere are some things you can do about making private health insurance work better for you
There are some things you can do about making private health insurance work better for you

There are some things you can do about making private health insurance work better for you

It’s worth having an open mind about Private Health Insurance (PHI) because far too many people end up paying too much for policies which can leave them feeling a bit sick..

If  you don’t want to be one of the disappointed here are a few thoughts which might save time, worry and even money.

We can’t do much about the above inflation increases year-on-year. On average policies went up by 6.2% on April 1 and that’s a very average figure. Some premiums soared by almost 17%.

You also have to suck it up if you’ve been means-tested out of the 30% rebate which already costs some $6 billion annually. The government wants to re-instate it but won’t say when.

And the various sticks and carrots to make young and old take up and stay in PHI and prop up the system, such as the Medicare Levy and Lifetime Health Cover, aren’t going anywhere very soon.

But what you can do is use the government’s independent information and comparison tools such as  www.privatehealth.gov.au  to get a commercially unbiased view of your options. It’s a great start.

If you don’t want, don’t like or can’t afford PHI there can be costs, which if you are younger add up over time, but there’s no obligation to take it out.

PHI is different from the kind of cover you might get for your home and car in many ways. It’s more complex, more regulated, more expensive but less focused on how good or bad a risk you are.

In some ways the lack of risk-based pricing is the key difference with general insurance which may benefit many of the over-50s reading this.

Thanks to a policy called community rating the premiums we pay for our health cover as older Australians are the same as those paid by any other customer—regardless of their age of health status. There’s no discrimination.

The health funds don’t advertise it but they seek more younger clients to offset the generally, and note this applies to averages not individuals, higher payouts to older customers as we begin to frankly wear out.

Of course there are plenty of those in their sixties who could run rings round far less fit generations but as we get on we tend to need more procedures and they tend to cost more.

So for us there’s an advantage for being in the system if you can afford it. But how to find the value? Around 10% of PHI customers or one million people switch funds each year trying to get just that.

Many are frustrated to find the cover they thought they had,  to say a knee replacement,  was actually an exclusion or not covered. There’s almost 50,000 different policy variations out there which is bewildering.

Also as the costs go up those too focused on the price as opposed to the value they might get chase lower-priced premiums by downgrading  their cover.

There’s been an explosion in what are called exclusionary or  restrictive PHI products recently to cater for this demand .

It’s the simplest way to save but while it makes sense to drop maternity services if you are of pension age many more have made poor decisions.

A recent survey suggested 39% of respondents  automatically renewed their PHI every year probably without reviewing it to see if the cover was still right for them and their families or if they could find a better deal with another provider.

At the very least you should check out the policy when the renewal notice arrives to see how it fits and also and look into a number of commercial comparison sites , as well as www.privatehealth.gov.au,  to see if there are better offers out there.

You may be surprised, in a nice way.

Originally posted on .

Join the conversation

FiftyUp Club
There are some things you can do about making private hearth insurance work better for you

Share your views with other members. 

Want to leave a comment? or .
Read our moderation policy here.
Gayelene
Gayelene from QLD commented:

My husband and I are with Queensland Country Health. My research has failed to find a fund that offers similar benefits for a cheaper or similar premium. Gayle 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

I am in HCF and I am told that if I switch to them I can save money. The same with energy, I am already with AGL which I am told I should switch to. When I moved to my present address last year I could not switch as I was starting a new account. I am over 60 and paying high costs for these services. Robert Baker 

Peter
Peter from NSW commented:

My health fund premium went up 20% on April 1. Nothing like the 6.2% they all stated. So I did my research and found a better and cheaper deal with Bupa which I have now joined. 

Someone
Someone from NSW replied to Peter:

The worst part? The CPI went up only 2 .3% ! What makes these crooks (the government allowing it and the health funds) feel that they can rip us off by THAT MUCH, to THAT EXTENT, by 20%, by ten times what the CPI is? Pathetic, abysmal the performance of both, the government and the health funds! Voting for another government will be a start... 

margaret
margaret from NSW commented:

So glad to read your comment. For some time I have wished we could compile a list of those things which have gone up more than twice the stated CPI. Health insurance, rents, elec. gas, hmes, car and home insurance, rates and it goes on and on and on. We could also list all those government fines, charges and changes that do not reflect the CPI percentage. To listen to our WONDERFUL government waffling on about CPI % when it suits them then completely ignoring it when it does not makes me think...got what we (well not me) voted for.Come on 50 up Club help your members compile that list even though there will not be any kick backs in it. 

Someone
Someone from NSW replied to margaret:

They are a bunch of hypocrites Libs voters, Margaret, as Christ said on the cross: "Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they are doing." And they divided up his clothes by casting lots, as the government of the pretend Christian of a fascist Tony is doing to the poorest, the weakest in our Aussie society, "crunching" to pieces our way of life... ... 

warren
warren from QLD commented:

Yes Pat, I agree as I have been with bupa since I was 16 the last procedure I was out of pocket $6000 when I asked why they said they only pay on the schedule fee of this medicare paid most of that and the health fund paid the balance ,which was not much. Why am I paying thousands of dollars only to be told they only pay on the schedule fee when the doctors charge what they like. ( also had to pay all up front before they did the job) The schedule fee needs to reviewed as these out of pocket cost are getting out of hand. If the 30% rebate was reduced or dropped I think there would be a huge drop out and one wonders if the health funds are riding this. Food for thought ...... 

June
June from NSW commented:

For persons over 50-100+ there should be no gap payments -Even if the funds charge us a bit more /:::Reason is this group at the best of times cannot claim their receipts or make extra payments too :: because of restrictions to age they cannot get to funds or cannot get on computers etc thus relying on relatives who all live busy lives / or carers Would be heaps more convenient if they were charged a bit more so there are no out of pocket expenses or taking receipts for claiming from funds There are heaps of us put there with the time restraining problems or even dementia patients - Help ! 

Maureen
Maureen from QLD commented:

Totally agree that it is the cost of the gap that is the killer - even with top cover health insurance that I have held since I was 16 a proposed procedure that I require sees me $6000 out of pocket. I am not having it because I can't afford it through the private system. In a perfect world where someone has health insurance there should be no out of pocket expenses and where a person chooses to not have health insurance, is known to be on a substantial income then they are prepared to take the risk of high fees from providers - public hospitals should not be expected to take them in. For those who don't have insurance because they can't afford it due to very low incomes then public hospital services with associated Drs/specialist should be readily available. The thing that annoys me is that Drs do not take into account that people who have PHI have already outlaid thousands of $'s each year to avail themselves of that service and to then have to turn around and still pay more is grossly unfair, and I suspect they load their charges as well, working on the thought that if you didn't have health insurance you would have paid from your own pocket anyway - so if you have health insurance you still pay some from your own pocket - just maybe not as much. 

Gordon
Gordon from NSW commented:

As a member of a Not for profit Funds since my teenage years I now find that the cost is high ( Now around 12 % of pension) but it gives you the choice of Doctor and Hospital and overcomes lengthy waiting times in the Public System. Had major surgery last year which would have meant my selling my modest home to meet the costs including rehabilitation.The other aspect is downgrading of rural Hospitals often when populations & need are growing ( ie; Cessnock and Kurri ,Bombala & Casino are good examples )No doubt many more . State and Federal Govts Wake Up 

Jenny
Jenny from NSW commented:

As an existing HCF member, we were unable to take advantage of the benefits obtained by the Fifty Up Club which was really disappointing. 

Peter
Peter from NSW replied to Jenny:

I got a better deal from Bupa. 

Patricia
Patricia from NSW commented:

I did some shopping around this year.I signed up with GMHBA and I am saving about $45.00 per month.The only difference was I will be going into a public hospital with a private room instead of a private hospital.Also Iget back 75 per cent of my extras paid. that is for a couple aged 59 and 69 years old and retired.Trish 

Peter
Peter from NSW replied to Patricia:

After my research and changing to Bupa, I am saving $75 per fortnight. 

Lynette
Lynette from QLD commented:

I think public patients should be mean tested as I know people that can more than pay for private health etc but go public which stops people who can not afford phi and hence the long waiting lists for operations etc 

Comment Guidelines