News

NewsLoyalty: A word born of an age of chivalry and worn thin in an era of competition
Loyalty: A word born of an age of chivalry and worn thin in an era of competition

Loyalty: A word born of an age of chivalry and worn thin in an era of competition

We’re hearing a lot of sound and fury about tax, but what about the voluntary tax many of us are paying worth more than $11 billion – without realising it?

The sting in the tail is, the older you are the more likely you are to be paying it, by 11% for every 10 years you age.

Welcome to the Loyalty Tax – the cold hard extra cash you pay in some perverse tribute – not to the government but to the providers of essential services who charge you more for staying true.

The good news is, there is something you can do and usually it’s easier than you might think.

First off: fill in our 2-minute loyalty tax test to see how much you’ve been losing - Take the test now

The mere effort of doing this might spur you into action which could prove surprisingly worthwhile

Loyalty is a word born of an age of chivalry which has been worn thin in an era of competition. If you stay loyal to your bank, power company or telco you are usually paying for the privilege.

The economists, who tend to know a bit about money, call this charity on your behalf the ‘opportunity cost’  defined as "the loss of potential gain from other alternatives when one alternative is chosen".

A simple example would be the $650 million consumers have saved in the past five years by switching to cheaper (usually not big bank) home loans.

Or $394 million for those who forsook a more expensive energy supplier for a cheaper competitor. Or the $325 million saved by those who changed telcos or home insurers for better deals.

The staggering sums are all examples of the loyalty tax which creeps like stealth through your life, silently siphoning off funds you could put to much better use.

Listen to Christopher Zinn speaking to Steve Price on 2GB about the Loyalty Tax Test

All these figures come from a recent study by the Heritage Bank and Queensland University of Technology. It looked into our collective switching behaviour and the massive savings or in more economist speak ‘ the money left on the table’.

They found while more than half of consumers considered seriously changing their home loan, insurance, energy and telco, less than a quarter actually ended up switching.

It’s those 20-25% who get out of paying the loyalty tax for life. Once they have experienced the savings it’s more likely they will carry on realising the benefits in savings exceed the switching costs such as time and effort.

Over the next week we’ll be looking more closely at the Loyalty Tax and sending you advice about how you can beat it.

Have you already taken the Loyalty Test? Leave us your comments below about what you learnt. 

 

Originally posted on .

Join the conversation

FiftyUp Club
Loyalty: A word born of an age of chivalry and worn thin in an era of competition

Share your views with other members. 

Want to leave a comment? or .
Read our moderation policy here.
Lori
Lori from VIC commented:

My mother wanted to switch energy & gas however Lumo said they would charge $70 exit fee 

Gertraud
Gertraud from ACT replied to Lori:

This means she is on a fixed term contract and needs to find out when it ends. 

Phil
Phil from NSW commented:

Click Energy's usage charges are higher, so despite their discount on Supply charge, I'm still much better off with Energy Australia. 

Phil
Phil from NSW commented:

Click Energy's usage charges are higher, so despite their discount on Supply charge, I'm still much better off with Energy Australia. 

sinikka
sinikka from NSW commented:

One needs to be savvy and ask questions. I have NAB no fee credit card, one year they told it will now have yearly fee I told them I have been excellent customer for many years and NAB will lose me as a customer if yearly fee was inow payable on my card. So no fees was introduced and I continued to be faithful NAB customer. I( charge everything to this card and each month pay full amount so no fees or interest ever! 

Julie
Julie from NSW commented:

when I got my Coles Mastercard it was free of the annual fee yes too good to be true did not last long after 18 mths. that`s right an annual fee in their system locked in yes. NO! Now they are heavy advertising no annual fee so when you`r in they change the rules. Beware as you can`t pay at Coles, The Post Office has a $2 charge added to your next bill, only Target, K-mart, but beware bring your card and your statement which you must print off otherwise you can not pay you bill free of extra charges. 

margaret
margaret from NSW replied to Julie:

Yep. The 'no free lunch', theory is often Oh So True. I decided 17 years ago, when my financial situation took a turn for the worst, to close my cheque account ...regarded as essential back then, plus my only credit card and and only have EFTPOS. There was a time, before I became a pensioner when I only had six free transactions per month including fortnightly rent. I remember the three monthly account that came in with 4x40 cent transaction fees and thinking I have not used so many transaction before. This made me really think where my money went and how it should be organized. A lesson that has been one of the most useful financial lessons I have learn t. Now I also have a savings account with that WOW 2% interest, same bank so no fees. The wandering around pulling out a credit card at any and every opportunity can allow one to spend far more money each month than one would if one was in the habit of giving real thought to the purchase. Of course I always carry a little 'mad money' with me and can use EFTPOS if I REALLY need to. The excuse ' I do not have time to pay bills', is in most, but not all cases, more an indication of someone needing a reality check and/or, a time and motion study then genuine lack of time. As for those offers of 'you beaut' cards......I tell them when their company directors give me all their personal details, I will respond with mine. Do not believe in the tooth fairy either. 

Gertraud
Gertraud from ACT replied to Julie:

I haven't paid a single cent in fees for my Coles Mastercard since I got it many, many moons ago. It appears that they have different cards, so maybe you should contact them and change your card? As to making payments, I simply log onto my bank account and pay all my bills on-line. 

Ivan
Ivan from QLD commented:

Like Gertrude, I shop around for my needs. I am currently with iinet for broadband but I don't think I get a very good deal at $59.95 per month for 50GB (25GB each download and upload), when my contract is finished I will bundle with Southern Phone Co. with whom I have had a landline for 9 years.as I can't find a better deal. The only drawback is you can't have your own email address with them, it has to be gmail or hotmail etc. I would never choose Telstra under any circumstances, nothing they have is a good deal. My car was insured with RACQ and included free accommodation, car hire and towing in the event of a mishap when travelling however I never needed it and am not likely to. I shopped around and chose Coles car Ins. which was a $200 saving. My electricity has been with Click Energy for three years, and you don't have to have a contract because nobody is cheaper, and a bonus is they have an Australian call centre if you need to speak to them (as do Southern Phone). Companies like Energex purport to save you money with silly hints like turn off everything at the power point. Well in a humid climate it is best to leave electronic stuff on standby to keep the moisture out of its innards. Also they never tell you a big way of saving power and that is to put your airconditioner in the dehumidify mode (the teardrop icon on your remote). This feels just as cool as when in the refrigerate mode and you don't have to have all the doors and windows shut tight for it to be effective. To save money you need to spend some time researching and comparing but it is worth it in the long run. 

Grace
Grace from QLD commented:

I did the loyalty test and was a bit taken aback that there was no option to tick for 'have paid off mortgage'. We have paid off all our debts including cars and credit cards and it was worth doing without in order to get to this point. While I still want to save as much as possible, I also feel that we have to look at our own spending habits. 

Jacqueline
Jacqueline from QLD replied to Grace:

Hi Grace, thank you for your feedback. You are right, the design of the survey accidentally omitted that option. Thank you for taking the survey. 

Gertraud
Gertraud from ACT commented:

My electricity & gas provider is ActewAGL, I receive discounts of 18% and 15% respectively, though the primary reason I stay with my current provider is the 50 cents gross feed-in tariff for my solar panels. For my insurances, I was with AAMI for quite a few years, however, they have become too expensive and I have progressively switched my car and home & contents insurances to Coles Insurance. I don't pay any fees or interest on my credit cards as I clear the balances each month. My landline/broadband service is currently with iiNet under a fixed term contract, I am not happy with them, so I will be shopping around when the fixed period expires. For my mobile phone, there is only one company I will deal with - Telstra. Granted, I pay a little bit more, but I enjoy the greatest network coverage. For my travel insurance I am covered by using my credit card when I purchase the flight. I have little interest in comparisons and assessments done by the various organisations such as Choice Magazine, Money Magazine and Investor Magazine, as these do not take everything into consideration. I much rather do my own comparisons based on my needs, consumption, and yes, even personal preferences, when it comes to picking providers. 

Paul
Paul from NSW commented:

I have been one of those individuals that usually says "If it ain't broke don't fix it" however, mainly due to awareness campaigns from the Fifty Up Club and Choice Magazine I have investigated whether I am paying a :loyalty tax" or not for several of my service providers. In some cases it has provided benefits. For instance I compared my car insurance renewal (GIO) with the one offered on the website and was able to get a discount. I asked my bank (CBA) to waive my annual credit card fee which they agreed. (It had been free for several years due to the level of business I have with the bank but suddenly they decided to re-introduce it). In other cases I found that I was already on one of the best policies (eg. CommInsure Home Insurance). What is challenging is reading (and understanding) all the fine print. For instance I found that if I changed my Telstra homeline plan I would have to agree NOT TO USE a third party provider for overseas calls so I would end up paying more for international calls. One concern I have with changing electricity suppliers is that if I changed then at some later point change back or the original or another, that I would be subject to more a stringent policy/plan (like Telstra have introduced above) such as to be billed via use of a Smart Meter which I have worked out is more expensive in my circumstances. 

Mark
Mark from NSW commented:

Loyalty. Could that be the word applicable to governments who see "oldies" as soft targets (such as the proposed kicking of oldies out of their homes)? Or banks who offer new customers great interest rates for depositors but refuse to extend the same terms to customers of 40 years (as St George did to me recently)? Or perhaps mooted changes to superannuation laws that almost inevitably will affect oldies who have already sacrificed to get themselves in a financial position where they are self-funded, yet there are no proposed changes to the unbelievable super benefits to politicians? Thew simple fact is that we oldies should feel no loyalty to any commercial entity or a particular government - except Australia as a nation. 

Comment Guidelines