News

NewsHealth funds get poor report, but some stand out
Health funds get poor report, but some stand out

Health funds get poor report, but some stand out

The nation’s health funds lodged their premium increase proposals last week to the Federal Government. Timely then that a survey by Roy Morgan out this week confirms satisfaction with private health insurers has declined to 2013 levels.

Results show more than 10 per cent of Australians plan to leave their funds in the next 12 months and are shopping around. Lucy Cormack writing in the Age this week reported:

The results, from Roy Morgan's Single Source survey of more than 50,000 Australians, found nearly all major health insurance providers had shown declining customer satisfaction in the past year, with overall satisfaction at 74.4 per cent, down from 76.3 per cent at the same time last year.”

The research revealed that over the past three years, HBF has maintained the highest satisfaction level of the five largest funds at 80.2 per cent, followed by HCF (74.3 per cent), Bupa (73.6 per cent), NIB (70.9 per cent) and Medibank Private (70.1 per cent).

Satisfaction scores with most of the largest 16 funds decreased in the past year.

Although nearly three quarters (74.4%) of private health insurance policy holders are either ‘very’ or ‘fairly’ satisfied with their provider, only 27.9% report being ‘very satisfied’.

The significance of looking at ‘very satisfied’ customers is that they are much less likely than any other segment (including those who are ‘fairly satisfied’) to either change to a different company or shop around before deciding what to do with their renewal.

Retaining customers is a key component of growing the customer base and as such, increasing the proportion of ‘very satisfied’ customers is an important metric to track and improve on.

Norman Morris, Industry Communications Director, Roy Morgan Research says:

“Price remains the primary reason that people shop around or change private health insurance providers, and any increase in rates normally attracts negative attention from politicians and the media. This research has shown that, in order to reduce the likelihood of their customers shopping around or changing funds, private health insurers need to pay more attention to increasing the proportion of their customers who are ‘very satisfied’. Currently, just over one in four customers are classified as being ‘very satisfied’ on average, yet they are the group more likely to renew without shopping and so increase retention levels.”

We asked members on social media:  Are you planning on switching? Do you think the switching process is easy? Here are some replies:

Patricia: 

We have been seriously thinking about dropping out......we are pensioners and its getting harder and harder to pay. We don’t have huge superannuation either to help us.

Anne Marie:

Already have [pulled out]. Insurance is a scam Tell people to give up alcohol, sugars, tannins, & exercise - good luck! Reap what you sow.

Have your say below in the feedback forum.

Originally posted on .

Join the conversation

FiftyUp Club
Health funds get poor report, but some stand out

Share your views with other members. 

Want to leave a comment? or .
Read our moderation policy here.
Trevor
Trevor from WA commented:

My wife and I were with Medibank private for years on a Corporate level. We looked at changing years ago but were told by staff that it was a great cover at a great price and not to give it up as it was now being grandfathered out. It was only when I had a dispute over my cover for glasses when I sat down at another branch with the lady who said I can put you on to another table which is cheaper premium and a higher level of cover, which I did. I asked, "don't you have some moral/ethical obligation to advise me that I could have been better off financially years ago to have made this change"? Answered "No". We must remember that these are "Insurance Policies". Something that you pay a lot of money for and hope you never use. None of these Funds or Banks and the like care about the customers they have, they care about the customers they DON'T have. Needles to say, I have changed to ahm. I don't know if they are any good or not because I have only made 1 dental claim in 8 months, but at least my premium went from what would have been $4300 a year to just under $2800 for a comparable cover. 

James
James from QLD commented:

Disappointed that once again the only benefit to 50 up members applies to new customers. As I have fed back to my fund time & time again, there are never any offers that a long standing loyal member can avail themselves. There are no, "no claim" bonus" schemes... not even to allow a certain percentage accrual of unused annual allowances such as dental etc. Loyalty is a two way street and it is about time all the funds realised this! 

George
George from NSW commented:

What's with this great health fund offer caper?? Currently I'm with "for-profit" NIB (a private company listed on the ASX) and paying $67.47 per month for basic hospital cover with a $500 excess. So I decided to phone so-called "non-profit" HCF for a quote on exactly the same cover, and they quoted me $77 per month!!! So-called "non-profit" HCF looks to be very much like a total ripoff! 

Theo
Theo from VIC commented:

I am not complaining on the services when they are being used. But the expense of it is becoming non affordable. Health insurance cost has doubled in ten years, one wonders what CPI stands for. And the health insurers are also saying, that maybe there are some services that you may not need and therefore when you take them out of your policy, you may later find that you need them. And if you wish to reinstate them you'll be in for a shock at the cost. So everyone is quoting: go shopping for a better deal. What a waste of time, because you can't compare apples with apples, you have to employ a solicitor to work out the fine print and the differences in these policies. And our Government doesn't really care. But they will when we all drop out. Every company in this country has to find new ways to make things work better. About time these private health companies do the same. I quote again: doubled in ten years. 

Casey
Casey from VIC commented:

A year or so ago, I took the advice to shop in different places for our hospital and extras covers, buying them from different companies. Now, however, we've decided to self-insure for dental and optical, as we hardly get ANYTHING back from these anyway, especially with their maximum limits. So now, we just pay for top hospital cover. 

Margaret
Margaret from NSW commented:

Am looking to change again in the next 6 mths. Although working full time, the cost of it compared to what I use, is ridiculous. Personally, I think private health funds generally, are rip off 

Gertraud
Gertraud from ACT commented:

I don't have health insurance, I have recently turned 70 and am as healthy as can be. I do admit to visiting a doctor on two occasions this year due to some nerve damage when I was around 30. Previous to this I saw a doctor back in 2011 - one visit every 5 years or so, that suits me just fine. And no, I don't do any tests. 

MAUREEN
MAUREEN from VIC commented:

Maureen: I have been with Medibank Private for many years. It's only now as a pensioner that I have needed to use my cover. I'm on an old policy and it used to cover everything in hospital, not anymore, found myself out of pocket for blood tests and I understand X-rays in hospital arn't covered now either. I am looking around for something better. Can't trust anything anymore. 

Beth
Beth from QLD commented:

A lot of pensioners will be dropping out. I had a conversation with my fund telling them that I will never use IVF or anything to do with pregnancy I would love to have that to cover things that I do need. I will never give mine up but I have started to look aroung 

Arthur
Arthur from NSW commented:

We have been with HCF for nearly 50 years and have been happy with the service when we have had to use it but we have reached a point the cost are now taking nearly half the budget that we set aside to run the household (not including food) at nearly $5000.00 per year it is way and above what we as Pensioners can afford. Arthur NSW 

Comment Guidelines