News

News40 years after Gough, are we better off?
40 years after Gough, are we better off?

40 years after Gough, are we better off?

gough-whitlamDear Fellow Members,

The death of Gough Whitlam this week (may he rest in peace), had all of us thinking of different times.

Like many FiftyUps, you may have found yourself rewinding 40 years and reminiscing about how different it was to live in Australia in the mid-1970s.

At the FiftyUp Club, conversation turned to whether we were better off.

In 1974 we were paying 30 cents for a litre of milk.

We were outraged when Federal Treasurer Frank Crean upped the price of a postage stamp from 10 cents to 18 cents.

A loaf of white bread cost 24 cents, and a kilo of rump steak was $3.24.

And petrol was less than 20c/Litre before the 1970s oil shock.

Ah, the good old days, when the average male income was about $150 per week, the age pension was $26 per person and so was the dole.

The average house price in the capital cities was just under $30,000.

Are we better off since the days of Gough as PM?

Today we pay $1.50 on average for a litre of milk – that’s 5 times the 1974 price (and no doubt it’s being kept low by the big supermarket discount wars on milk).

An average loaf of bread is $2.93, which is more than 12 times the 1974 price, despite the supermarket wars.

We hardly use stamps anymore, but they’re 70c – that’s almost four times the 1974 price. But email is much cheaper, fortunately.

Petrol is 8 times the price at an average of $1.50.

The average price of a home in 2014 is about $550,000 – which is 18 times what it was back then!

Overall, the Consumer Price Index calculated by the Australia Bureau of Statistics has risen from 14.7 in 1974 to 105.9 today, which is a little over 7-fold.

But Australians’ average weekly earnings are about $1500, which is 10 times what it was in 1974. The aged pension is now a bit over $400 or about 15 times the 1974 rate.

So theoretically, we should feel better off. Some boffins like this one argue we just spend more and expect more these days. But is it as simple as that? We think not.

We paid upfront for healthcare before Medicare (or Medibank, as it was first called), but we weren’t paying an average private health insurance bill per couple of over $3000 in 1974.

There was no such thing as a broadband bill back then, or a $2000-per-household power bill – as some of us now pay.

Gough was a political locomotive in a hurry to reform Australia by crashing through or crashing. Fortunately there are many positive legacies, and they were affectionately acknowledged by all sides after news of his passing age 98.

As Tony Abbott said yesterday: “Whether you were for him or against him, it was his vision that drove our politics then and which still echoes through our public life four decades on.”

But governments since the 1970s are kidding themselves if they think they’ve done their job by making us all better off since Gough.

As FiftyUps we can be grateful for Medicare, free Education, Women’s Rights and the Rights of our Aborigines.

But we should keep campaigning for governments around Australia to keep one eye on what it costs to live in this wonderful country of ours.

Originally posted on .

Join the conversation

FiftyUp Club
40 years after Gough, are we better off?

Share your views with other members. 

Want to leave a comment? or .
Read our moderation policy here.
maureen
maureen from NSW commented:

we are for sure 

Christine
Christine from QLD commented:

I don't know why Gough Whitlam is so revered by many but I suspect it is because he gave handouts to people who otherwise would not have been entitled to or need them. And of course, people will keep voting for a government that gives them money for nothing. We see that philosophy continuing with political parties to this day. Gough Whitlam may not have ruined the economy of this country but he certainly blew huge holes in it that are still there today; he had to be stopped and that opinion was borne out by the results of the election after he was removed from office. I remember the shortages on supermarket shelves; the rampant inflation. As a whole are we better off, I don't think so. One legacy from the Whitlam era is the wages increases that saw low and no skilled workers being paid too much for their work and that legacy is hurting the economy right now. How many businesses have moved production offshore because the wages in Australia are so uncompetitive? How many businesses have closed because they can't compete with foreign imports. Yes, we may have been a closed economy, but we did produce most of our consumables, we weren't subject to the vagaries of world currency fluctuations and there was very little foreign ownership of our manufacturing and primary industries. It goes without saying that you could ask 12 economists for an opinion on the Whitlam reforms and you would get 13 opinions, but I personally think Australia is a little bit worse off overall for Gough's three years of government. 

David
David from NSW commented:

David NSW you are all hinting to the same thing the downfall of the economics in this country started with the withdrawal of the white Australia policy by Gough Whitlam permitting oversees in this country by non Australian nationals. I served three years in Vietnam yet refuges to this day still receive better and more substantial handouts than Australian born citizens. Vietnamese refuges were being given more benefits at that time than the service personnel that served in Vietnam that was the downfall of the good life in Australia good for those coming in but not for those that served. 

jeanette
jeanette from QLD commented:

I don't think so to-day we seem to be working for overseas companies as we import all their goods and then sell them on for them how does that make sense and we don't get value for our money 

Carole
Carole from VIC commented:

I remember the "It's Time" campaign - so exciting and visionary and then when Gough got into power it all turned into a huge disaster. For those who are saying he provided "free" education - nothing is free and you can be sure some poor person was paying for that big time; many lost their businesses and life savings. 

Anna
Anna from NSW replied to Carole:

Oh Carole, Why is it that Australians believe that Governemet hand-outs are 'FREE"...you are so right. "They" even have the temerity to call their Dole payment,(taxpayers $'s;), PAY DAY!!!!!! Sad, Sad, Sad.. Nothing in this life is free, however, EGW;KR:JG, again that poor man KR,who should never entere public life due to his PD +WS, went ahead and spent "our" hard-earned $'s without batting an eyelid. Why then, didn't the then Opposition block Supply; call a Double Dissolution or whatever it took? We, i.e Australians, should be assured, that any person with Political ambition should have to undergo Mental Health Assessments and the appropriate tests to ascertain their capability of running an entire COUNTRY!!!!!!! The old-boys Club is closed. 

Sharon
Sharon from QLD commented:

He sent the country to the wall he destroyed the small farmers took away the subsidises which never returned. He had no economic credibility whatsoever. 

Bob
Bob from QLD commented:

No one man has ever excited the entire community like Gough did. He was a natural born leader, but not necessarily a good manager. Gough created the excitement, the possibilities for all Australians to prosper. But then as now, sneaky greedy bastards worked behind the scenes to ensure a select few would share the spoils. I honestly believe that Gough had his heart in the right place, but the bastards behind him had their hands in the till. They were allowed to spawn a new culture, which saw lies, greed, and stupidity as a 'normal' process. Commonsense, rights, fairness, loyalty, honesty, community spirit, respect, were all put to the sword in the interests of greed and stupidity. Whitlam played a role, as did all his successors on both sides of the political fence, but more importantly, the people of Australia allowed it to happen. They recited chapter and verse when I was young ... "All it takes for evil men to do bad, is for good men to do nothing.... and now we are trying to go back in time and BLAME someone else for our own failings ... I really do not have the answers on how to fix the mess we collectively created, but you cannot go back and blame one individual for all our current woes 

Norman
Norman from QLD commented:

Water is the tough expense, it was free then, and many of us had water tanks, but councils forced us to remove them in the 1970's or 80's and rely on Governments. Bah humbug! 

Greg
Greg from QLD commented:

We should look outside the country at Gough's legacy. Papua New Guinea under Australian stewardship, was a safe and happy place to live. He gave them independence, which they were not ready for. That place now is a money guzzling basketcase. I was there in 2008. I don't think it has improved. West Papua given to the Indonesians without any referendum from the people living there. The good things are certainly out weighed by the lack of good policy in regard to our next door neighbours . 

brian
brian from QLD commented:

all the comments i have seen or heard are typical funeral comments,"what a lovely bloke"etc when in fact the opposite is fact.does nobody remember the khemlani ,juni morosi,affairs,lionel murphy lost his seat,and was immediately appointed a high court judge <rigging the system>.arrogant ass,denied liberal pre selection so went to labour to exact revenge.repealed menies white aus policy,still think that was a good idea.???? 

Comment Guidelines