News

News Power Cuts or Power Bill Cuts – Does it really come down to a choice?
 Power Cuts or Power Bill Cuts – Does it really come down to a choice?

Power Cuts or Power Bill Cuts – Does it really come down to a choice?

Who do you believe – the energy regulator charged with putting the long-term interests of consumers first? Or the NSW ‘poles and wires’ companies which actually deliver the stuff? 

That’s essentially the argument behind a high stakes legal stoush which will determine the size of planned 5-12% reductions to your next electricity bills.

And it’s especially important for older Australians who generally face higher bills. They are at home more, spend a higher proportion of their income on electricity; and are hit harder by climbing supply charges.

But those big savings promised to consumers are now under threat as the poles and wires companies and the NSW state government which owns them launch legal appeals against planned price cuts due on July 1.

So the FiftyUp Club is going to launch an appeal of its own: from today we’re asking you, the members, to send us your views on the legal battle, and tell us how higher electricity costs have impacted on your wallet and way of life.

Click Here to have your say by answering a few questions and commenting in our FiftyUp Forum

Read on to see what’s at stake, send in your comments and ideas and we’ll package them up for the tribunal hearing the case to ensure your voice is heard.

THE FULL STORY

The Australian Energy Regulator (AER) has fixed a five-year pricing determination which cut the amounts the NSW state-owned poles and wires businesses could charge us by some $6 billion to 2019.

It adds up to big savings for the consumer of between $100 and $300 a year depending where you live. It is aimed to bring the costs of delivery to NSW households in line with those levied by the privately-owned networks in SA and Victoria. Presently they can be twice as much.

We’re told those networks are more efficient and employ less workers, delivering lower costs to consumers. Falling demand for electricity means there’s also less need to build expensive ‘gold plated’ networks.

It was the massive investment and poorly controlled spending in the high-tech and high-cost ‘poles and wires’, including pylons and transformers, which saw many bills blow out by more than 70% in the past five years.

Network costs can add up to almost 60% of some people’s energy bills especially if they live in the higher cost of service rural areas.

But the NSW government and their poles and wires companies have lodged appeals to the Australian Competition Tribunal, claiming the cuts to their revenue mean they can’t operate safely or reliably.

They are backed by the trade unions as 2,200 jobs are at stake. The network companies say they have already shaved more than $3 billion and 3000 jobs from their capital and operating programs.

They also claim the cuts mean they can’t manage vegetation growth in rural areas, which, as the 2009 Victorian bushfires demonstrated, can carry serious risks.

Their arguments may sound convincing but have drawn fire from numerous quarters.

The ALP says the AER’s decision is fair and the NSW Government only wants to increase the waning value of the networks – a large part of which are up for a $13 billion long-term lease.

Groups representing consumers, welfare and business have also attacked the appeal and the Public Interest Advocacy Centre has brought its own legal challenge arguing for even bigger spending cuts on the networks.

To have your say, help us put together a submission to the Competition Tribunal.  Spend a few minutes answering the snap poll above on how power prices have affected your life, and leave a comment in our forum below.

We will report back soon on the next steps and make sure the voice of FiftyUps is heard.

From Christopher Zinn & The FiftyUp Club Team

Useful Links:

Daily Telegraph, 21 May, 2105, "Networks NSW will appeal energy regulators decision to cut the price of power bills for consumers": www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/nsw/networks-nsw-will-appeal-energy-regulators-decision-to-cut-the-price-of-power-bills-for-consumers/story-fni0cx12-1227363388780

Sydney Morning Herald, 21 May 2015, "Electricity price cuts, privatisation plans under threat as power networks set up fight with regulator": www.smh.com.au/business/electricity-price-cuts-privatisation-plans-under-threat-as-power-networks-set-up-fight-with-regulator-20150521-gh6meh.html

The Australian, 21 May, 2015, "NSW power networks to fight cuts in court": http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/nsw-power-networks-to-fight-cuts-in-court/story-e6frg8zx-1227364313737

 

 

 

Originally posted on .

Join the conversation

FiftyUp Club
Power Cuts or Power Bill Cuts – Does it really come down to a choice?

Share your views with other members. 

Want to leave a comment? or .
Read our moderation policy here.
Warren
Warren from NSW commented:

Suggest all bloggers ignore NSW 'A' comments in future. Apart from the extraordinary length of the voluminous/numerous inputs, they don't make any sense or am I missing something. Anyway, I note the energy legislation passed through the Upper House last evening. 

Someone
Someone from NSW replied to Warren:

Never too late to learn English Warren, especially you, with your knowledge of the Ocker Linguo, you would have a head start... 

Someone
Someone from NSW replied to Warren:

and if you don't mind, Warren, THIS IS NOT YOUR SHOW, no no no non no, mate! Bloggers can decide for themselves... Go learn the English language... 

Alain
Alain from NSW commented:

Fine by me, if you can afford to have the Libs at the helm of Australia, many cannot afford "them" too costly fr 'em, you must be loaded... 

Alain
Alain from NSW replied to Alain:

MY REPLY ABOVE to BARRY from NSW (Sorry for any inconveniences, it ended up up there for some reason...) 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

JUST LOOK AT WHAT NSW VOTERS RUBBER STAMPED YESTERDAY (Data sources: Annual reports, IBISWorld): Executive pay: Networks NSW $4.4 m Vic Power Networks $8.0 m Employees NSW 12,745 Annual Revenue: Networks NSW $6.9 bn Vic Power Networks $1.43 bn Employees Vic 2,012 The senior management salary bill would be expected to grow from its current $4.4 million a year to something much greater than the Victorian company's $8 million, given the much larger revenues and employee numbers. If the salaries matched their Victorian counter-parts in proportion to the revenue of the companies, the remuneration of ten senior executives would grow to $39 million a year, a nine-fold growth. However, it is likely that salaries would only increase in the first instance a factor of two or three. 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

(continued 2 of 2 ) Media comment: Greens NSW MP John Kaye said: "There will be big winners if the Baird government gets its way with electricity privatisation but they won't include households and small businesses. "The senior managers of the state's power networks can look forward to substantially larger pay packets which could cost households up to $10 million a year. "It's not hard to understand why the corporate elite like privatisation. It creates more high-end management jobs on salaries they understand, despite its impact on households and employees. "The senior management of AusGrid has been keen to take down the posters from groups that are critical of the Baird government's asset sales. "It's easy to see why managers looking at doubling their salaries without changing jobs might be keen to silence any criticism of the wires and poles sell-off," Dr Kaye said. 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

If the NSW electricity distribution networks are privatised [THEY NOW ARE THANKS TO NSW VOTERS AND ONE REVEREND], households and small businesses can expect to be paying for senior management salaries that are more than twice what they are now, according to Greens NSW MP John Kaye. The Greens today released a comparison of the executive pay of the senior management of the publicly-owned NSW distribution networks and the privately-owned Victoria Power Networks Pty Limited. Both have 10 senior managers, but while the Victorian network company earns only one fifth of the revenue of the NSW combined wires and poles entity, the ten senior executives earn 82 percent more. Networks NSW is a substantially bigger network, covering all of the state. Vic Power Networks covers only part of that state and is substantially smaller. The senior management salary bill would be expected to grow from its current $4.4 million a year to something much greater than the Victorian company's $8 million, given the much larger revenues and employee numbers. If the salaries matched their Victorian counter-parts in proportion to the revenue of the companies, the remuneration of ten senior executives would grow to $39 million a year, a nine-fold growth. However, it is likely that salaries would only increase in the first instance a factor of two or three. This comparison is consistent with a number of international studies that have exposed dramatic increases in salaries for the senior managers of privatised public utilities The release of the data comes after reports that the Baird government had paid up to $20 million to UBS for advice on the lease process. (http:// j.mp/AFR150325) The previous Labor government spent about $200 million on advice from bankers, lawyers and stock brokers for negotiating its power sell-off. (1 of 2 .../...) 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

Brisbane Times EXCLUSIVE (To give you an idea of whom you put in power downunder, you seem -with the sale of Poles and Wires- to have an enormous faith in the Libs...): Highly sensitive details of the negotiations over the little-known Trades in Services Agreement (TiSA) published by WikiLeaks reveals Australia is pushing for extensive international financial deregulation while other proposals could see Australians' personal and financial data freely transferred overseas. The secret trade documents also show Australia could allow an influx of foreign professional workers and see a sharp wind back in the ability of government to regulate qualifications, licensing and technical standards including in relation to health, environment and transport services. In its largest disclosure yet relating to the TiSA negotiations, WikiLeaks has published seventeen documents including draft treaty chapters, memoranda and other texts setting out the overall state of negotiations and individual country positions in a secret bargaining on banking and finance, telecommunications and e-commerce, health, as well as maritime and air transport. The leaked documents were to be kept secret until at least five years after the completion of the TiSA negotiations and entry into force of the trade agreement..../... Read the rest in the Brisbane Times (Philip Dorling 3rd of June) 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

The leaked TiSA documents can be found at WikiLeaks.org. 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

THE COALITION... What party does Barnaby belongs to, you...? 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

Was in reply to Warrens comment: "LNP? Get you're fact rights. The Libs are in power in NSW not LNP?????" 

Warren
Warren from NSW commented:

Nationals 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

That is what you do all the time, Warren! Speak for urself! 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

My reply above to Warren's comment: "It's a real weakness in your character to drag someone down in order to build up your own case. Very poor form NSW 'A'." 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

FYI (This "says it all"...): http://nsw.greens.org.au/news/nsw/big-winners-power-sell-bankers-and-managemen 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

It tied to prepare and reduce costs. Worked to buy efficient appliances. Bought solar panels. I'm still working. The bills didn't reduce significantly and I get next to nothing for the half of the energy i produce that I send back to the grid. I have to effectively buy back my own power at a high rate to run heating in the evenings. Should have had a holiday than try to plan to reduce costs for retirement. 

Someone
Someone from NSW commented:

Storage of your own power will soon be more affordable and less voluminous, should fix your problem, anonymous... 

Comment Guidelines